The word “budget” is not a cozy and exciting word. In fact, it conjures up a painful image of entering numbers into a green ledger with a quill. Because of this negative association with budgeting, I don’t enjoy making budgets and have had to fool myself into saving money.
Here is the process I use to budget for retirement. Admittedly I am only tricking myself, but this process does work.
1. First I estimate the money needed for the necessary monthly bills: Mortgage/rent, utilities, insurance, car payment, loans and property taxes. I then put these bills on auto pay.
2. Then I add 10% to my monthly budget to cover unexpected costs.
3. Next I determine how much to deposit into my IRA or 401k for the coming year.
4. Because it’s easier for me to pay a bill than to put money aside, I create a fictitious loan that I have to pay back in monthly installments based upon what I determined in step #3
5. This next step is important: I have my employer automatically deduct the monthly “loan payment” amount from my paycheck and put it directly into my retirement account.
6. Next I decide how much to spend on food and gas.
7. The remainder is what I have available for discretionary spending and regular savings. I get to choose how much to spend and how much to save.
8. Now I get three envelopes and label the first “food”, the next “gas”, the last one “fun”. I then go to the bank each month and pull out the allocated funds for each category and put the associated cash into the envelopes. I further divide the cash by 4 or 5 depending on how many weeks are in the month and note the amount on the front of the envelope. This is what I take out each week. It’s my personal allowance. I carry my weekly fun money with me but I only take out the food and gas money when I’m heading out for those activities.
9. I spend the fun money without guilt but stop when I have no cash left.
10. This is key: pay everything in cash. I don’t touch my ATM card or credit card. If I do use either of these, I remove the same amount of cash and deposit it into my checking account to cover the payments.
11. At the end of the month, whatever that has not been spent or is left over in one of the envelopes; I put it into a non touchable investment account. If you have credit cards or other loans outstanding that are non deductible, this money should go to pay it down first.
12. If I feel like splurging in the coming month or have a big ticket item, I sometimes move the extra money forward and add it to next month’s spending allowance.
For an extra zing on savings – I actually choose to allocate my 401K allowance into 6 equal payments, not 12 payments. This means that in July, after the 401K has been maxed out, I suddenly have a large amount of money each month that has no allocation. I typically put these excess funds into investments.
It takes me ten minutes to set everything up including the paperwork. My priorities are set up front and I am on auto pilot for the entire year. It’s amazing how well I live within my means and the decisions I make about spending when I see the cash in my wallet and know that this is all I have to spend.
Does this mean that I live without any luxuries? No, far from it. Luxuries are important but I define what it is to me. My decisions on spending are now conscious ones. I can look at my weekly fun money and say “I’ll carry this forward until next week because I want to eat at my favorite sushi restaurant or because I want a pair of gorgeous shoes.” What do I give up in return? It might be that I choose not to go to any fast food takeouts for the week or buy that random $20 blouse.
The process gives me the ability to spend money freely and without guilt or self doubt. In return, I found that the freedom to spend actually reduces my spending dramatically. The option to indulge at any time made me discriminating. My internal dialogue tends to go like this.
Oooh I like that. That’s how much it costs? Do I really need this or do I just want it? I want it! Hmm, is it worth it? or do I want to go to San Francisco next week more?
There have been weeks at a stretch where I keep accumulating the fun money because I never found anything worthwhile to buy. I used to be a big shopper. I rarely shop now except for food or specific needs and wants.
I have used this process for years to stay within budget and achieve my financial goals. It’s financial budgeting without the hassle of finding a green eye shade to match my ledger.
What are the tricks you use to build your savings?
© 2010 MoneyandRisk.com all rights reserved





Very clever, Kim. If it takes tricking yourself to ensure you save money then who am I to argue?
Thanks for the interesting article!
Best,
Len
Len Penzo dot Com
Len,
Thank you for visiting.
The process works great for people who have no self control and the unconscious spenders.
I love tip #4. I would love to see a post geared towards us who don’t get a steady paycheck. I’m a massage therapist in private practice so my income is fluctuates.
Enya,
That’s a great point. My income fluctuates as well and always has since I left college because I consult. I’ll think through my process and put it down. It’s so automated for me by now.
Interesting approach. I’m not surprised that it works so well. Lot’s of discipline!
I have a comment/question about your 401k approach:
“… I actually choose to allocate my 401K allowance into 6 equal payments, not 12 payments. This means that in July, after the 401K has been maxed out…”
Kim, I just curious if this approach allows you to receive any company matching amount after you have already maxed out for the year. Do you get matching amounts ? And do they match for the rest of the months in the year after you maxed out ? This calculator helps spread contributions to a 401k over the year for someone who has a predictable income.
http://webpages.charter.net/savenow010/401kcalc.html
Lee, I do check out the company matching policy carefully before I do this to make sure that I get the full match. Although I was with large firms for years, the most that I ever got by maxing my 401K was $2,000 /yr. My small business clients match more than that for their own employees.
What this process does is that I maximize the company’s match within three months. If I leave the company, assuming it’s not on a vesting schedule, I didn’t lose out on the match for the remainder of the year.
By the way, I was giggling a bit at your comment about discipline. This process is actually meant for people who have no self control or who doesn’t want to mess with budgeting like me.
Hi Kim, you are so organized! I think that really this is the bottom line – being organized. I have a 403b plan at work but they don’t allow the flexibility of clumping the contributions together like you mentioned but that is a great technique.
I’m glad you stressed the importance of paying down credit card debt! Nothing can be more liberating.
Thanks!
Ileane,
The process is dependent on the adviser for the plan. I handle 403bs as well and we make the plans flexible to encourage savings. Note that 403bs now have to be transparent and going through regulations similar to the 401K plans starting this year.
Hopefully, your employer will do their due diligence and review the 403b to change things up.
I don’t think you can stress the part about spending fun money without guilt enough! Unfortunately, when people don’t factor in the fun money the tend to overspend and then get riddled with guilt! Great Post!
Thanks Jason. I think life is too short to spend it on unearned guilt.